Saturday, 5 March 2022

Young Bridge Challenge 2022

Last year after the excitement of the Peggy Bayer home internationals my bridge playing youngsters carried their form into the UK schools championship, finishing 3rd (read here: British Schools Challenge 2021)

This year they are hugely improved players, barely recognisable from 12 months ago. Last year we were discussing Stayman, this year it's Jacoby 2NT. However, learning new conventions has probably done as much harm as good, the real improvement has been in judgement and defence.

Although they have got better the competition has also improved, and this year there were 22 teams. That included a combined High School of Glasgow and Kings College team, featuring my top pair from S2 (aged about 14).  

The format was four rounds of five-boards, then the top-four into the semi-final and final. Due to the seeding we had a touch match against Eton in the first round, a team we have had two close matches with already in the Interschools League.

On the first board East-West had 12 tricks in Diamonds and Hearts, but had to contend with every Junior's favourite weapon, the weak opening.
 

When the Eton North opened 3♠ our East (Harry Stuart) bid 4♦, and although South bid 4♠ our West (Alexander Duncan) bid 5♦ and played there.

On a Spade lead this took the maximum twelve tricks for 5♦+1.

On the other table our North (Kevin Ren) was allowed to play in 4♠. 


The defence took two Hearts and played Diamonds, leaving declarer a Heart loser and the Club suit to deal with. Rather than ruff a Heart with trumps still out, declarer chose to draw trumps first, then ruff a Heart, which found him stuck in dummy. However, leading a low Club from the South hand made life difficult for West, who put in the Ace leading to just one down.

Across the 22 tables the most common result was 5♦+1, with a couple of pairs finding the slam and one getting away with 7♦=.

After a few more swings we won this match narrowly to start with 14/20 VPs.

Next up was St Pauls C, who were the only team fielding a substitute adult - overall it's impressive that with 90 children playing there was only one didn't make it to the start line. The Glasgow team won this match too with a series of small swings, most notably when St Pauls played 2♠ in both rooms!


When East was declarer he must have been rather disappointed with the 7-0 trump split, but you must also say well done to our South (Michael Kennedy) for not doubling 2♠.

Across the field the most common result was South going down in Spades, Diamonds or NT.

After this we were up to 28/40 VPs. With things looking good we next had the Raffy Sinclair team. 

First off we lost 6 IMPs on this one playing in the wrong game:


4♠ looks good until you notice all the Spades in the South hand. You can nearly make it, but can't quite ruff a Club in dummy, and get the Queen of Diamonds. We lost 6 IMPs playing 4♠-2 in one room and conceding 2NT+1 in the other.

The most common result was East-West making eight tricks in Spades or nine in no trumps.

We followed this board by a 3NTx-4 where no one did anything particularly wrong, but it cost a lot, leading to our third match adding just 1 VP to the total. This put us on 29/60 VPs and unlikely to qualify.

In the final round we had St Pauls C team. Our pair who were just chastened in 3NT showed no fear and did it again, this time reaching an impressive 5♣x-6. Luckily they were non-vulnerable so it only cost 1400 points.


The immediate reason for the disaster was running out of trumps, the real reason perhaps not being on the same wavelength about the strength of an Unusual 2NT.


Playing 5♣ is an interesting exercise in damage limitation. In general, when you have a weak two-suited hand like this, the key is to play the second suit as early as possible, even before drawing trumps. This is because you don't mind if they ruff your second suit, in fact it even helps you keep trump control.

Most tables had East-West making game in NT or Spades.

This mishap proved the catalyst for some excellent play, and the team went on to win this match comfortably. Alexander and Harry finished in style as the only pair to bid 6♣.




Not a comfortable contract, but a making one when Harry guessed Spades right. Note that 6♣ is a much better contract than 6♠. In 6♣ your trumps are solid enough to survive a 4-1 split, and you can also delay choosing who to play for the Queen of Spades until later in the hand when you might know more. 

The normal result was East-West making game in Clubs or Spades.

With this storming finish we took 19 VPs to finish on 48/80. As the final table shows, this was not quite enough to qualify:


Given that Lucy Norman, Raffy Sinclair and Nina Mauve are all people and not schools, we were in fact 5th of the eligible teams, just 2 VPs behind a semifinal spot. Oh well.

In the plate the team played well, with Michael and Kevin doing especially well, to secure some consolation silverware.

Congratulations also to the junior Junior Pair of Niamh and Rachel, who played nicely throughout and were above average on the Butler rankings. 

They would have enjoyed this one:


 

It's not a perfect bidding sequence - why didn't East reply 1♠? - but my younger teams have been focusing on play, and it was indeed played nicely.

North led a Spade on which our declarer (Rachel) threw a Diamond. Later when South was on lead he tried a low Heart. Declarer put in her T♥ and lost just three tricks overall (two trumps and a Diamond), making with an overtrick a contract that could have gone down.  

The overall event was won by Haberdashers A beating Loughborough in the final.






  

Sunday, 20 February 2022

2022 Peggy Bayer Home Internationals #2

It looks like we finished 3rd, well behind Ireland in the end. 

Peggy Bayer Results

Today we overbid a bit and got doubled against England, then underbid a bit, then got it about right, bidding a lot on distributional hands only.

Before the final match I told my team there was always a slam on the last board, so Aidan had no difficulty finding the raise to 6♣ here.


South led a Diamond and that was an easy 12 tricks. It looks at first glance that on a safer lead 6♣ might fail, with both Diamond and Spade finesses offside but actually you can set up the Spades and always make it. I was impressed how quickly my team pointed that out when we were looking at the hands afterwards.

After nine rounds I'm pretty tired, so the team must be doubly so. They've played well and been a credit to Scotland. Here's 4/6 of them, with me in the corner.






Saturday, 19 February 2022

2022 Peggy Bayer Home Internationals #1

This year I am the non-playing captain (NPC) of the Scotland U21 team. Over the weekend we'll play multiple matches against England, Ireland and Northern Ireland (no Wales this year). We have three pairs, and since it's all virtual this year my main job is selecting the pairs and submitting our lineups. The team are all very well organised and punctual and so from that point of view it's been very successful.

As for the bridge, we started with a 20-0 win against Northern Ireland, followed by a 0-20 reversal against England. In the crunch match against Ireland I watched some of it with my partner from the SOL league, John Faben, and his six-month old baby. This was the board that caused most discussion:


Straight away it looks like trouble, with two strong but misfitting hands. On the other table the Irish North-South bid to 3NT, which looks like a good result. With tricks all over the place even baby Xander could make this one and the Irish declarer duly wrapped up 3NT+2.

On our table North started with 1♣ then bid Spades and Spades again after the fourth-suit-forcing 2♦ bid, which I think does nicely shows this sort of 6-5 hand. After that South has a problem. He went for 4NT, which is presumably Blackwood, in Spades? (It wasn't alerted and I haven't asked him).

North showed one keycard and South signed off in 5♥, and who knows what's happening now. Anyway they got to 6♥ which is a playable spot.

With the trumps and Clubs behaving nicely it can make, but could also be very awkward too.

Not wanting to lead away from any honours, West started with a trump. East did well to withhold the Queen, letting the ♥T in dummy win. Declarer is now home by drawing trumps and giving up a Spade. He did well to start immediately with a Spade from dummy (East might just play low with the Ace). When West won and returned a Diamond it was all over. Declarer drew trumps and claimed 12 tricks.

A rather fortuitous 13 IMP gain.

It wasn't enough to stop us losing to Ireland, 58-24 for a paltry 2.69 Victory Points. I always think the Victory Point scales are much to extreme in these Junior events, where you expect a lot of swings.

After this we beat Northern Ireland again and lost to England again. In that final match we lost 66-7, for a morale boosting 0.07 VPs.

These are the standings after Day One:

Tomorrow we will try to take a little more off England, and crucially beat Ireland so we can come second overall.


Thursday, 10 February 2022

Rowan vs St Mungos

This has been a relegation season for Team Rowan, finishing bottom of Division 1. For our last match Anna and I put in a good performance. With some good defence and some fortuitous overbidding I would say we were slightly above par on our table, at least until the last two boards were we missed a couple of difficult games. It helped that the speed of play was quite fast, which certainly helped my concentration.

On Board 10 I was faced with an absolute textbook hand. How do you play 3NT on the lead of the 6 of Hearts?

The first thing to note is that you don't have enough time to set up the Clubs. You have to lose the lead twice, which means they'll have knocked out your Ace-King of Hearts. You will then lose three Hearts and two Clubs.

If Hearts are 4-4 you are OK though. I therefore ducked the first Heart. When South followed with the 4 of Hearts on the secound round it looked like Hearts were 5-3 (at least). Over to Spades then. I unblocked the Diamonds (perhaps a mistake) and played a Spade to the Ace then a low Spade. I planned to duck this, but North popped up with the Jack. I can now establish a Spade trick by force, but never get to it, as I have no more entries to hand. So I had to duck this Spade. This so confused South he overtook with the ♠Q and I fortuitiously had nine tricks.

The best line in thie Spade suit in isolation is to play the Ace-King. This gains if anyone has honour-doubleton, and I'm always OK if they are 3-3. My line appeared to give benefits when Hearts are 4-4, but actually just messed up my entries.

On the other table my counterpart Mike McGinley got it right - just winning the fist Heart with the King and playing the top Spades.

Overall we lost the match 10-6, which for the team that's bottom of the league was quite a good result.

Wednesday, 26 January 2022

Rowan vs Kenmure Lions

A more relaxing game tonight. Afterwards when we thanked each other on the final board the words nice, pleasant and pleasureable were used.

Our opponents were less agressive than in previous matches, which worked well for them here:

With North-South silent Anna and I got to 3NT. Anna has a singleton Spade and knows I have only three, but reasoned that 3NT was probably still our best contract. And if my Hearts and Spades were the other way round it would have been. As it was the defence efficiently took the first five tricks for 3NT-1.

At the one other table where North-South passed the result was also 3NT-1. When South overcalled 1♠ at one table they played 3♠-2, and only once did East-West get to the top spot of 4♥. Well bid Neil and Anna. On a Spade lead I think the best play in 4♥ is to duck the first three rounds, but with trumps 3-3 everything works.

Anna's bold 3NT there might have been influenced by an earlier board, where we floundered in 3♣+1 with 3NT making. But I think with the hand above Anna can afford to bid 2♥ on her last turn, then when I fail to bid NT she'll know Spades aren't stopped.

Finally here's a hand where the opponents showed good technique:

On Anna's King of Diamonds lead declarer is in trouble, at risk of losing one Spade, two Diamonds, and the Heart finesse. But declarer correctly played on Clubs before tackling trumps, and could discard a Diamond loser to make exactly. Even if Clubs are 4-2 this play doesn't cost anything. I'm not sure but I think it might be even safer to cash the Ace of Hearts first, then if Clubs are 4-2 and an opponent ruffs they could be ruffing with the ♥K.

Three times the result was 4♥= and the fourth table played 5♥-2.

Overall we narrowly lost the match 8.5-7.5

Sunday, 23 January 2022

Rowan vs Wanderers

Our newly promoted Team Rowan have lost their last three matches 16-0, including this one. On our table Anna and I were up against Derek Sanders and Gints Freimanis, who I have played alongside a little in the SOL league. They gave us a sound beating, getting to and making a lot of games.

Anna and I played OK. We made two mistakes failing to get a game, plus I expect our defence wasn't as challenging as it could have been. 

However, at the start of the match I'd say we were briefly ahead. Near the start they drove to slam with a flat 10 count opposite a 2NT opener (6♥-1), then we had a go at our own slam:

My first bid of Jacoby 2NT showed a game forcing raise in Spades. Anna could have shown a second suit or a singleton, but instead went for 3NT which for us shows six losers. When I bid 4♣ I was pleased to see her cuebid Diamonds, then I signed off lacking a Heart control. Anna had one so bid on, getting us to the decent spot of 6♠.

At least it's decent until East led a Heart. At that point there appears to be two inescapable losers. There is one legitimate line of play - to play Diamonds from the top hoping that one defender has ♦Jxx and also has the ♠A singleton. When they ruff your fourth Diamond away goes your last Heart. Anna instead went for sneaking a trump through before playing Diamonds, but it didn't work. Three of the four tables played 6♠-1, the other 4♠+1. The leads were a Club or a Spade, after which declarer must have thought they were going to make 12 tricks until they found the bad Diamond split.

Next I found myself in a tricky 4♠.

The auction is confusing but we ended in a decent spot. West led a Heart and you can see dummy and declarer have mirror distribution. This suggests an endplay.

After East took his two Hearts he switched to a Club. I won with the Ace (saving the ♣J), drew trumps, got the Diamonds right, and finally conceded a trump to West. He had the choice of leading Clubs round to my ♣KJ or giving me a ruff and discard. Either way it's 4♠=.

Except that's not what happened. After taking the first Heart East found an immediate Club switch. Now I'm scuppered. When West gets back in he can safely play another Heart across to East who plays the killing second Club. One off. It was great defence from both of them.

On the other tables it was 4♠-2 twice (declarer getting the Diamonds wrong) and once 5♣-4 from the Wanderers North-South. So in fact this board was a rare profitable one for Team Rowan.

Not making that game (but knowing how to) was the high point for me. After that we slipped somewhat, culminating in a 6000+ point defeat overall. 

Although the defeat was comprehensive there was some luck involved, both for us and against, as these two hands demonstrate:

Gints and Derek play a relatively simple system, and 2♦ was natural (and not game forcing). Anna therefore felt she could weigh in with 2♥. It's one of those occasions where bidding 3♥ might actually have been safer (as I won't play her for having so much defence). When the opponents got to 3NT, I fancied a double. I know that they've chosen to bid 3NT, but I figure with my Spades and Clubs sitting over declarer (and presumably partner has smoe Diamonds over West) it's not going to play well at all.

Plus, on the last hand they doubled me in 4♥ when things were sitting badly and I went two off, giving me more confidence it was the right thing to do.

However, here the Diamonds are running and declarer has 10 tricks in 3NT (the Spades are blocked but after taking all his winners declarer can play a Club from dummy and ends up with a tenth trick).

West passed the double of 3NT but East removed to 4♣. I felt obliged to double that, and also 4♦ when that came round.

This needs us to find at least one ruff to beat it, and we did. Anna led a Club to my Queen, and I returned a Heart and got a ruff. I still have my ♣A for one down, a great relief as I thought they were about to make 4♦x. As Anna pointed out afterwards I can give her a Club ruff, and maybe should have, but thought it might be declarer with a singleton Club so didn't want to risk trying to cash my ♣A getting it ruffed and letting the contract make.

On the other table West opened a very strong 3♦ and played there. The defence did get both ruffs for one off, so our gain was not what I hoped (but better than them making 3NTx+1).

On this last board I felt hard done by as it was the one board that the opposition didn't bid game on, despite having the values for it:

Anna's cheeky 1♠ opening left them in only 2♥, but the 5-0 trump break means 9 tricks are the limit. At the other table Colin and Sheena did well to find 4♥ but lost out as it went one off.

Friday, 31 December 2021

HSOG Bridge Christmas Party

For the Juniors Christmas party I made up some boards that had already been played at the Buchanan Bridge Club. That meant even if we played a board only once I could generate a score for each pair by comparing with people who had played it previously. I chose hands from a Matchpoint evening with 26 tables, so each deal had a maximum score of 50 (2 points from beating each of the other 25 pairs), so I could double those scores to get a percentage.

For example:

When this deal was played our East-West pair duly made 3NT+2. So they get the same score as the other pairs who made 3NT+2, 27/50 or 54%. That turned out to be from our most experienced Junior pair, Niamh & Rachel, who won the event with 64%.

Although the double-dummy solver says the optimum contract is 7♥ it needs trumps 3-3, so is far from wise. 7♣ is better, but actually (as is usually the case) you can forget about the grand and bidding any slam will get you a good score.

Perhaps West opens 1♦, North ovecalls 2♠ East doubles, West bids 3♣ then East can drive to 6♣. Would our Senior pairs have bid it? Maybe.

The full results of hands from the Buchanan club can be found here: Buhcanan Results 10th May (then click on Travellers).